The NYC & Long Island Neighborhoods Nobody’s Talking About (Yet)

by Latisha Dash

Everyone knows about Astoria, Garden City, and Huntington. But what about the neighborhoods no one’s talking about? The ones where first-time buyers can still find space, community, and value before they blow up?

Here are a few hidden gems worth watching in 2025:

Elmont (Nassau County): With the new UBS Arena bringing life (and jobs) to the area, Elmont is becoming a commuter-friendly option with strong upside.
Ridgewood (Queens/Brooklyn border): Once overshadowed by Bushwick, Ridgewood offers the same artsy vibe with larger homes and tree-lined streets.
Baldwin (South Shore Nassau): Waterfront potential + community feel = major draw for families priced out of Rockville Centre.
St. Albans (Queens): Rich history, single-family homes with backyards, and easier access to Long Island make this area a quiet sleeper pick.
Brentwood (Suffolk County): Large lots, diverse culture, and new development plans mean this area has room to grow.

👉 The Bottom Line: If you only look where everyone else is looking, you’ll pay the premium. First-time buyers win big when they spot the “up next” areas.